a guest post written by Big River Jake
Hello dear readers, this is Big River Jake coming to you for the first time in what I hope is a regular vehicle for me to package together what little thoughts I have, and transfer them into your brain via text. If all goes well this will be entertaining, because I have no delusions that it will ever be informative.
The QnD on the FN Five-seveN
Quick stats
Manufacturer:FN Herstal
POU: PDW
General Design: Semi-auto Pistol (Poly)
Action of Arms: Delayed Blowback
Chambering: 5.7x28mm
Weight: 21.4oz
Barrel Length: 4.8in
Capacity: 20 round DBM
My entire lack of experience with the Five-seveN lasted 100 rounds of ammo. Overall fun to shoot. First thoughts on the gun was how good it felt in the hand. I know way too much clout is put into how good a gun “feels” or “points”, but what struck me about the Five-seveN is how much it feels like a steel frame gun. I have handled a lot (very specific number which has never been documented)of Poly guns, but none have the bottom heavy feel of a big steel frame with a lighter steel slide. A Glock feels about balanced, and my little Kel Tec PF-9 feels top heavy, but the Five-seveN has a bottom heavy steel frame weight distribution.
Second thoughts you say? Quality, quality, quality I say, and for the MSRP it damn well should be. One hiccup on the particular rental gun I am reviewing (the USG model) the magazine was less than reliable and had some chewed-up bits which I am most certain was the cause of two failures to feed. After I received a different Mag from clerk, I did not experience any more failures. Also of note, the trigger pull was deliberate,consistent, and intuitive.
Final thoughts, are cloudy. I think the firearm looks very good in most on paper gun reviews due overall to how well engineered and manufactured they are. I am also aware of how many forum wars have been waged on the 5.7x24mm cartridge. All this in mind, I don’t see many people ask the basic question of “does this Gun fill it’s POU?”. I would have to say “Yes”. That POU being a NATO replacement for a PDW 9×19, with better terminal ballistics against soft body armor. That being said US civilian sales are a telling sign that it does not meet the Philosophy of use for personal defence in social situations (or lawful response to dynamic critical incidents). Basically this is the part where I throw the gun review out the window and rant about the 5.7x24mm. The loading that FN sells to Civilians are not adequate to comparable 9×19 loads available. Current Loads can be found online )wikis), but are summarized in one word “improvable”. The 5.7x24mm concept in a 5in barrel has potential, but from evidence I’ve seen (see links) all over penetrate, even when the bullet performs as intended (yaws, or expands). Perhaps if someone was to bring out a new load which would not overpenetrate (maybe a hollow base bullet design like the 5.45x39mm at 2500fps in a 5in barrel) I would completely change my mind considering the complete lack of recoil and shootability, but as it stands right now I would have to say the Five-seveN does not fit any need I, or any readers lifestyle. Unless your lifestyle includes dispatching prairie dogs with ubertacticoolness at 15 yards from a Bugatti.


iTunes
RSS Blog Only
Twitter – Jason







